theREBUTTAL – A Political Cafethe REBUTTAL – A Political Cafe

death to pacifist monks

by Stefan Koski

Published: March 25, 2008

The area of Tibet (let’s not lend it credence by calling it an “occupied country”) has long been a sore issue with Chinese bureaucrats. Obstinately positioned on China’s geographical western border and periodically insisting on a political status of - depending on who you talk to - somewhere in-between autonomy and full independence. Look, just because its people boast different customs, a different language, culture and spiritual leader in the form of the Dalai Lama, doesn’t mean they aren’t Chinese.

In the last couple of weeks, the Tibetans have been at it again, peacefully demonstrating at first, but then morphing into violent riots when Chinese law enforcement tries politely to disperse them.

China has tried to export its growing financial success to the western province of Tibet over the last decade in many ways: creating tax incentives for Han Chinese businessmen to open up shop in the Tibetan capital of Lhasa, giving contracts to Han Chinese contractors to build shopping complexes and the Qinghai-Tibet railway, transforming old run-down neighborhoods into bustling new business sectors. The result has been unrivaled economic growth (for Han Chinese businessmen) in the region.

The pessimistic Buddha-huggers will say that the economic system set up in Lhasa gives preference to Chinese workers and entrepreneurs, marginalizing Tibetans in their own homeland. From there they’ll tack on all the other complaints typical of rebellious Tibetan nationalism - how the Dalai Lama still isn’t permitted to return to Tibet, how exiles are sometimes shot for trying to cross the border into Tibet to visit relatives, human rights abuses ad nauseam.

All of it detracts from the overwhelming good that China has done for the region. Not everyone can share in its economic success. That is the nature of capitalism. Some people will naturally expand and thrive in the modern world, and others will simply disappear, assimilated by the populations and cultures around them. No big deal.

Much to the dismay of Chinese officials, Tibetans refuse to disappear despite all of the efforts they have made toward that end in the last half-century. These latest riots, just four months before Beijing hosts the Olympic games, only further proves their unwillingness to cooperate with an industrially and materialistically superior nation. The Chinese are thus left to their usual recourse: dispatching thousands upon thousands of troops to heroically do battle with downtrodden peasants and monks armed with prayer wheels.

We can only hope that the international community will obligingly look the other way, as it has done so often in the past.

—

(email this article or post to social network)

—

Leave a Reply

HOME

theSOCIALISTS

  • conservative
  • the badge
  • race and obama
  • ...

theDEMOCRATS

  • word of mccain
  • suspension
  • you, hillary
  • ...

theMODERATES

  • philosophy
  • obama prophecy
  • home stretch
  • ...

theREPUBLICANS

  • police state
  • king obama
  • energy to believe
  • ...

theLIBERTARIANS

  • (R) and (D)
  • drinkers
  • gettin's good
  • ...

theARCHIVES

theWRITERS

ABOUT

RSS

theRECENT COMMENTS

Dave MacCallum on the philosophy of policy

"U know how to tell if a politician is tell a lie? His lips are moving. U know how to tell if U..." (6 days ago)

dana on To Our Readers

"soon i hope!" (10 days ago)

jane on To Our Readers

"yes please!" (10 days ago)

NHred on throw the bums out!

"s/b term limits" (13 days ago)

NHred on throw the bums out!

"what about trem limits? Now there’s an idea who’s time has come!" (13 days ago)

The Nation
Actual Politics

theMOST POPULAR

theHOT POLITICAL LINKS

Times Online:

Russia engages in 'gangland' diplomacy as it sends warship to the Caribbean

WCBSTV.com:

Sen. Clinton: 'No Doubt' Obama Will Win

Seattle Times:

Bill Clinton says he understands Palin's appeal

My Fox Colorado:

5th Grader Suspended For Anti-Obama Shirt

Boston Herald:

UMass chaplain fails in effort to boost Barack Obama’s chances

Fox News:

Homeland Security Detects Terrorist Threats by Reading Your Mind

LA Times:

Sarah Palin said yes, thanks, to a road to nowhere in Alaska

NY Times:

Saudi Women Find an Unlikely Role Model: Oprah

FactCheck.org:

McCain ad misrepresents Obama's tax plan. Again.

Bloomberg.com:

U.S. Stocks Rally Most in Six Years on Plan to Shore Up Banks 

NY Times:

Fed’s $85 Billion Loan Rescues Insurer

LA Times:

E-mail to Obama: dishonest TV ad, wrong audience

© 2008 - theREBUTTAL™ & HITWP, LLC - All Rights Reserved - Contact: hr@therebuttal.com