theREBUTTAL – A Political Cafethe REBUTTAL – A Political Cafe

a win for obama is bigger than politics

by Aaron Rodriguez

Published: January 9, 2008

I owe a lot of people in this nation an apology. Back in February of 2007, I scoffed at Barack Obama’s candidacy. I believe my exact words were “There’s no way that white people will vote for a black man in a presidential race.” In my defense, I wasn’t the only one with this mentality. People might not be as cynical as I am, but for a lot of African-Americans, the idea of an Obama administration is a pipe dream. But facts are facts, and the fact is he won in a state that is 92% white and finished a strong second in New Hampshire. I should have had more faith in my countrymen.

I’m sorry.

Still, one must wonder why I and so many others were pessimistic about Obama’s prospects. He easily won his bid for the senate in 2004; he’s an incredible orator and a brilliant man. Yet for some reason, I encountered few African-Americans who thought he had a real shot, and I live in Chicago. Now, I don’t speak for every black person in America. So I don’t want anyone to think the politics of African-Americans are one-size-fits-all. But one only needs a brief introduction to black stand-up and sketch comedy to see that the idea of a black president has been a surefire way to get laughs. So, many of us continued on dejectedly awaiting the inevitable Clinton victory, but in the past two weeks we’ve seen a glimmer of hope. If a black man can win over Iowa, then a black man can become president.

Of course, a few moments after his victory I began thinking to myself, “Am I supporting the man or the message?” Despite what’s been said on Fox News, Barack Obama isn’t all that liberal. He’s hardly progressive and on African-American issues he’s been virtually silent. If he were elected we wouldn’t be any closer to eradicating many of the problems that plague the working class. It might not be business as usual, but Obama wouldn’t usher any radical change. As a socialist, it’s hard for me to justify voting for a man whose actions would uphold the status quo. Even still, I can’t shake the feeling that I should do it anyway.

While this seems like a compromise of values, I’m not supporting him because his policies are particularly inspiring. On major issues, the top three democrats are nearly indistinguishable. Regardless of who gets elected, the only “change” we’re likely to see will involve bastardized universal healthcare. The battle for affecting national public policy is not going to be decided by November. However, it is possible to turn this into a mechanism for social and psychological change. We could very well see the first non-white president in US history. The impact of such an event will exceed any policy decisions made by our current crop of politicians.

Now before anyone gets offended and shouts “You’re only supporting him because he’s black,” let me say two things:

First of all, there are going to be plenty of people who won’t vote for him because he’s black, so at worst I’m counter-acting that sentiment. Secondly, while Barack Obama the policy maker won’t enact fundamental reform, Barack Obama the figurehead will. What could do more to eradicate the nihilist world views of so many minority youths than seeing someone who looks like them running this nation? Leaders inspire people, not legislation.

The Obama administration won’t end gang violence or turn every public school into fine academic institutions. However, it would definitely do a lot young black people good to see that such powerful positions are not the exclusive property of old white men. If we want to see real change, not this empty media buzzword, we must cultivate a generation that doesn’t just accept the world they are handed. Obama’s most powerful act will most likely be shattering our image of what American government has to be. If Obama winning an early caucus can restore a little of my faith in our ability to rise above racial divisions, just imagine what Obama winning the presidency will do.

—

(email this article or post to social network)

—

Leave a Reply

HOME

theSOCIALISTS

  • conservative
  • the badge
  • race and obama
  • ...

theDEMOCRATS

  • word of mccain
  • suspension
  • you, hillary
  • ...

theMODERATES

  • philosophy
  • obama prophecy
  • home stretch
  • ...

theREPUBLICANS

  • police state
  • king obama
  • energy to believe
  • ...

theLIBERTARIANS

  • (R) and (D)
  • drinkers
  • gettin's good
  • ...

theARCHIVES

theWRITERS

ABOUT

RSS

theRECENT COMMENTS

Dave MacCallum on the philosophy of policy

"U know how to tell if a politician is tell a lie? His lips are moving. U know how to tell if U..." (6 days ago)

dana on To Our Readers

"soon i hope!" (10 days ago)

jane on To Our Readers

"yes please!" (10 days ago)

NHred on throw the bums out!

"s/b term limits" (13 days ago)

NHred on throw the bums out!

"what about trem limits? Now there’s an idea who’s time has come!" (13 days ago)

The Nation
Actual Politics

theMOST POPULAR

theHOT POLITICAL LINKS

Times Online:

Russia engages in 'gangland' diplomacy as it sends warship to the Caribbean

WCBSTV.com:

Sen. Clinton: 'No Doubt' Obama Will Win

Seattle Times:

Bill Clinton says he understands Palin's appeal

My Fox Colorado:

5th Grader Suspended For Anti-Obama Shirt

Boston Herald:

UMass chaplain fails in effort to boost Barack Obama’s chances

Fox News:

Homeland Security Detects Terrorist Threats by Reading Your Mind

LA Times:

Sarah Palin said yes, thanks, to a road to nowhere in Alaska

NY Times:

Saudi Women Find an Unlikely Role Model: Oprah

FactCheck.org:

McCain ad misrepresents Obama's tax plan. Again.

Bloomberg.com:

U.S. Stocks Rally Most in Six Years on Plan to Shore Up Banks 

NY Times:

Fed’s $85 Billion Loan Rescues Insurer

LA Times:

E-mail to Obama: dishonest TV ad, wrong audience

© 2008 - theREBUTTAL™ & HITWP, LLC - All Rights Reserved - Contact: hr@therebuttal.com